How to choose a house sitting platform: 7 things to check
House sitting works because two people who have never met trust each other: you let someone live in your home and look after your pets, and they give your home and animals their time in exchange for a free place to stay. The platform in the middle decides how much of that trust is backed by anything. These are the seven things worth checking before you pick one, with the questions to ask. At the end you'll see how FairSit answers each of them, including where it is limited.
Updated October 30, 2026
What it costs, and who pays
Platforms make money in different ways: a membership paid by owners, by sitters or by both, a fee on every booking, or a commission. Before you sign up, find out who pays what, and whether money passes between owner and sitter at all.
The price matters less than whether it is clear. A price you can read before you pay is a good sign.
- Is there a booking fee or a commission on each stay?
- Is the membership annual or monthly, and can you cancel and keep access until the period you paid for ends?
- Does the free plan let you actually complete a stay, or only look around?
How identity is checked
A 'verified' badge only means something if you know what stands behind it. Ask what is checked (an ID document, a selfie matched to it, just an email address?), who can get the badge, and whether it can be bought without being checked.
Also ask what the badge does not mean. An identity check tells you that a real, named adult is behind the profile. It is not a guarantee of character, so it should be one signal among several.
Whether the reviews can be trusted
Reviews are the most useful thing a profile has, and the easiest to distort. If the other person can read your review before writing theirs, or can answer it, both sides learn to say nice things. Look for a system where nobody sees the other's review until both are written. That is called double-blind, and here is how it works.
Also check that reviews come from completed stays only, and whether you can reply publicly to one you receive.
A written agreement for every stay
Most house sitting problems come from expectations that were never written down: which rooms are off limits, how often the dog gets walked, who pays for what. A good platform gives both sides a written agreement to read and sign, with the dates, the pets, the house rules and the cancellation terms, and a copy for each of you. What a good agreement includes.
What happens when plans change
Flights get cancelled and people get ill. What matters is what the platform says before it happens: when a cancellation is acceptable, what the sitter is owed if the owner ends a stay early, and whether a pattern of cancellations is visible to the next person who considers that member.
- Can either side cancel a confirmed stay for any reason?
- If an owner ends a stay while the sitter is living in the home, who is responsible for the sitter's accommodation?
- Are repeated cancellations recorded where others can see them?
References and profile depth
A new profile has no reviews yet. References from people outside the platform, such as a neighbour whose dog the sitter walked for years or a family they sat for before joining, fill that gap, but only if they are confirmed. Ask how: a reference the sitter could write themselves is worth little.
Read the profile itself too: how detailed it is, whether there are photos with animals, and whether the person answers your questions before you commit.
What the platform does not do
Look for a clear answer to four questions: does it run criminal background checks, does it insure the home or the pets, does it compensate for damage, and does it act as a judge if you disagree? A platform may do none of these, which is fine as long as it says so. The ones to be careful with are those that let you assume otherwise.
The checklist
- Do I know exactly what it costs, and who pays?
- Do I know what its verified badge is based on?
- Can the reviews be trusted, or can each side see the other's before writing?
- Will we both sign a written agreement for this stay?
- Is there a clear cancellation policy, and is it enforced?
- Are references confirmed by someone other than the sitter?
- Does the platform say plainly what it does not do?
Whatever the platform, talk to the person before you decide. A video call and a few specific questions tell you a lot.