Blind reviews in house sitting: how they work and why they're more honest
A review is only useful if the person writing it felt free to be honest. In house sitting that is harder than it sounds: you have just spent days in someone's home, or they have trusted you with theirs, and you may want to be invited back. Blind reviews are a simple way to take that pressure away. Here is what they are, how they work on FairSit and how to get the most out of them.
Updated October 30, 2026
Why reviews get too polite
Imagine you are about to review a stay that was fine but not great. If the other person has already written theirs, you can read it first. If it is glowing, writing something critical feels rude. If it is critical, you are tempted to answer in kind. And if you know they will read yours, you may soften it to avoid a bad one back.
Each of these is a normal human reaction, and each pushes reviews towards polite and similar. The result is a profile full of five stars that tells the next person very little.
What double-blind means
In a double-blind system both people write their review without seeing the other's. Nothing is shown until both have written, or until a fixed time has passed. Nobody can read first and answer second, so the only thing left to write is what you actually thought.
How it works on FairSit
- The sit ends and is marked complete. The homeowner and the sitter are both notified and can review each other.
- Each has 14 days to write a review, with a rating from 1 to 5 stars and a comment.
- Nothing is published while the window is open. Your own review stays visible to you; the other person's does not.
- If both have written, both reviews are published together straight away. If only one has, it is published when the 14 days end.
- Once the 14 days have passed nobody can write a review for that sit any more, so waiting to see what the other person wrote is not possible.
- After publication, the person who was reviewed can post one public reply.
Two details: a sit that is cancelled before it starts can't be reviewed by either side, and reviews show the reviewer's first name only.
How to read reviews as a homeowner
- Look for specifics. 'Lovely, would recommend' says little; 'Followed the feeding routine and sent an update every day' says a lot.
- Read the lower ratings and any replies. How someone responds to criticism is information too.
- Check the dates and the number of reviews. One review from a long time ago is thin evidence.
- Read reviews next to references and the verified badge. They answer different questions.
- Remember they are one input. Talk to the person before you decide.
How to write a review that helps
- Say what happened, not just how you felt: dates, tasks, what went well and what could be better.
- Be fair and kind, but don't leave out something the next person would want to know.
- Write about the stay, not about the person's character.
- Write within the window. After 14 days it is too late.
- Remember it is blind: you don't need to guess what the other person wrote.
What blind reviews don't do
Blind reviews remove one kind of pressure, not all of them. A rating still reflects one person's view of one stay, a first-time sitter has no reviews at all, and a review can't replace asking questions and meeting by video before you agree. That is why references, a verified badge and a written agreement matter too.